cublikefoot

Reviews and Stuff

About My Reviews

Review Tidbits

  • All of my reviews are my own honest, original thoughts
  • I consider myself a gonzo journalist and will often write from a first-person perspective. My reviews are a whole lot more subjective than they are objective.
  • I use the entire rating scale and my ratings are largely subjective. While I may spend more time discussing a game or film’s positives, more so than its negatives, that does not mean it deserves a rating over 5. I give it the rating I feel it deserves as a whole.
  • All screenshots are my own, taken from the video file produced while recording the game. If not then they are screenshots provided by the developer/publisher.
  • Any writeup published could possibly be altered as time goes on. Any alteration made will be explained in said writeup.
  • Corrections are made to any writeup published if said writeup needs it. For example, if something is stated about a game that is incorrect.
  • I do not alter reviews as the result of updates, patches, etc. My review reflects the experience at that time. If I were to do so, then I would be updating hundreds of reviews that have since received updates.
  • I avoid allowing game developers or publishers to influence my reviews/first impressions. I could care less if they hate me after I write a review, if the game is bad, then I am going to say so.
  • Spoilers will always be avoided. Always.
  • As of March 17th, 2014, I no longer factor a game’s price into my review of said game. I made this change because my view on game pricing is very skewed when compared to the majority view. I rarely think any game is worth more than $10.

ACTUAL Game Reviews

  • My goal with ACTUAL Game Reviews is to provide reviews that have not been influenced by developers, publishers, etc.
  • I also make use of the ENTIRE rating scale. No more 7/10 being “average”, 5/10 should be average. 9/10 should be rare and given only to ACTUALLY good games. This is the same scale I have been applying to my anime ratings for years.
  • These reviews are usually written in a pro/con format, listing some outstanding pros and cons that I feel should be mentioned. I will not go into every aspect of the game, just the ones that I feel should be discussed.
  • A video review may accompany this type of review, usually an edited version of the written review (score included at the end of the video as well) lasting about four minutes.
  • If a video review is made and needs changing, changes will be made to the written version of the review and mentioned in the video review’s description.
  • I usually will beat the game prior to doing this type of review, but may review it earlier if I believe I have experienced enough of it (especially for longer games).

ACTUAL Impressions

  • ACTUAL Impressions posts are usually used when looking at early access games, but can also be used for released games that I simply did not want to review for my ACTUAL Review series.
  • These impressions are done with three games at a time and are given a corresponding video discussing those three games.
  • A bit shorter than a normal review. Gives an overview of the game without assigning a numeric score to it, instead just a thumbs up or down.
  • Games here can later on be covered in the ACTUAL Review series, but rarely so.

The Scale

I use a standard 1-10 scale, with half-points allowed. It looks something like this:

Score: 2/10

Score: 5.5/10

Score: 9.5/10

I also have a special rating I made for H-games that I end up reviewing because I feel they do not belong on the regular scale. That is this rating:

Lenny

The Old Scale

I use my own scale dubbed the “K-o-Meter”.

1- Not Really k
Given to bad games/movies/whatever, think 1-2 on a 10-point scale
2- Somewhat k
Given to games/movies/whatever that aren’t that great, but aren’t trash. Think 3-4 on a 10-point scale
3- Moderately k
Given to games/movies/whatever that are mediocre. Think 5-6 on a 10-point scale
4- Pretty k
Given to games/movies/whatever that are mediocre. Think 7-8 on a 10-point scale
5- Highly k
Given to games/movies/whatever that are mediocre. Think 9+ on a 10-point scale

Normal Reviews

  • Either a “Cub Plays” video would be created to accompany this type of post or a full-length series.
  • Review scores are not discussed with either the developer or publisher prior to the publication of said review

Review in haiku

  • A “Cub Plays” video will be created for said game, or an entire series featuring the game
  • A haiku will be written and placed onto a cool image from the game
  • A score will be assigned to the game, along with a short list of pros and cons
  • Review scores are not discussed with either the developer or publisher prior to the publication of said review

First Impressions

  • “First impressions”-type posts are usually used when looking at early access games, but may also be used for released games (usually those with longer length).
  • Either a “Cub Plays” video would be created to accompany this type of post or a full-length series.
  • A bit shorter than a normal review. Gives an overview of the game without assigning a score to it.
  • Could possibly become a full-length review later on.

Updated on:

2018-05-23: Updated the impressions section to reflect the new ACTUAL Impressions series and clarified why reviews are not altered due to patches/updates.

2018-01-27: Added bit on why my ratings may not reflect the content of the review.

2018-01-25: Added bit on gonzo journalism and expanded on why I do not factor price into my reviews. Also added explanation of the rating I assign to H-games.

2017-11-01: Added information about the pro/con format of my ACTUAL game reviews.

2017-10-05: Added info about how I review longer games (under both review and first impressions sections).

2017-10-04: Removed old “normal review” section and replaced it with the newer “ACTUAL review” section.

2017-09-22: Updated the scale, the “K-O-Meter” is now the old scale.

2017-09-05: Updated the “first impressions” section to reflect how I intend to cover early access titles. Changed the “game reviews” section to accurately reflect how I intend to cover most games. Also changed the ordering of the sections on the page.

2017-08-11: Add tidbit about using screenshots from dev/pub. Modified 1-10 scores on the K-o-Meter

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: